Should We Say Something? Knowing When to Make a Public Statement

Kristen Caloca • March 5, 2025

Generational changes and societal shifts have led many individuals to expect nonprofit organizations (and other workplaces) to take a stand and issue public statements in response to local, national, or global events, especially during times of crisis. Many nonprofit leaders have contacted me after feeling pressure from staff or the board to address certain issues publicly, asking, “Should we make a statement about this event? It doesn’t seem directly related to our mission. And if we do, does that mean we’ll be expected to speak out on similar issues in the future?”

An organization’s internal audience of board and staff is important and must be considered alongside the needs of external audiences. However, demands from any vocal audience group should not be the sole deciding factor when considering whether a statement should be made on a certain topic or event. Knowing when to speak out is, at its core, a strategic decision. When advising nonprofit leaders on this topic, I often begin with a set of questions to help them reflect and explore what is truly needed. These questions include:

  1. Does this issue impact our ability to carry out our mission and vision daily?
  2. [If the answer is ‘No’] Does this issue directly affect the physical or emotional well-being of staff, hindering their ability to fulfill the mission?
  3. [If the answer is ‘Yes’] Consider what your key audiences need to know, highlight shared values, and outline actionable steps that align with your mission. This is just the beginning; more can—and likely should—be done to ensure the response is genuinely authentic rather than merely performative.
  4. Does this issue directly affect our partners and intersect with our mission? If so, how?
  5. Am I responding solely to staff or board pressure to speak out? If not, is there another reason, as a leader, that speaking out on this issue aligns with our brand values?

By this point in the conversation, nonprofit leaders typically begin to gain clarity on what to do and why.

Since many nonprofit staff members are highly empathetic and care deeply about issues outside their workplace, there will be moments when external events affect some staff but don’t impact the organization's mission. Staff may urge leadership to take a public stance on an issue motivated by their personal values and opinions. In such cases, internal communications may be the best response rather than issuing a public statement on your website or social media.

Sharing your decision-making process with staff and explaining why and when you make public statements fosters transparency and builds trust in your leadership. Acknowledging staff concerns, even if you can't resolve them or hold differing viewpoints, is a powerful way to make individuals feel seen and heard—rather than leaving them uncertain about whether leadership shares their values.

Seth Chalmer, a communications leader at nonprofit Leading Edge, shared his experience with this in an article published by the Stanford Social Innovation Review on deciding when to speak out publicly on issues:

“Norms that prevent needless and unproductive arguments are great, but reluctance to touch controversy often goes too far. If everyone is too nervous even to mention that people in the organization may hold divergent views about a hot-button issue, that’s a recipe for enormous tension if and when the subject becomes unavoidable. If we neglect the skills of working together across important differences internally, our organizations will be in enough trouble that what we say or don’t say in public will be the least of our concerns.”

At times, an issue may directly affect your partners, and it's crucial to show up and stand in solidarity with the organizations you collaborate with to drive impact. This may not mean a public statement is still necessary; consider the means and method of showing your support and what is most needed at that moment.

Even after making a decision on whether to speak out, leaders should evaluate their actions and recognize the need to continuously adjust and refine the approach as they gain insights into the outcome of their decision. I firmly believe in adaptive leadership, which emphasizes continuous learning, among other benefits. An adaptive approach by nonprofit leaders in situations like this will benefit both them and their organizations. While we make the best decisions we can with the information available at the time, it doesn’t mean those decisions shouldn’t be reassessed as circumstances evolve.

To assist in navigating these difficult situations of knowing when to say something and to who, I’ve compiled several resources, including real-world examples from nonprofits, checklists, flowcharts, and informative articles. These tools can help guide your decision-making process on whether your organization should issue a public statement, address it internally, or take no action. Click here to view and download these resources.

What other frameworks have you used to help determine when it’s time to speak out on an issue? Email me at Kristen@KMCStrat.com to share your tips, and we’ll add them to our next Resource Roundup in our Field Notes newsletter.

Recent Posts

By Kristen Caloca • September 28, 2026
I was recently invited to attend the 2026 Next Narrative Summit in Florida, where conversations ranged from narrative change and foresight to culture, organizing, AI, and the role of philanthropy in this moment. I came home with pages of notes, but four key ideas have stayed with me, particularly as I think about the leaders and organizations we work with at Kairos who are trying to navigate a lot of uncertainty while still moving their missions forward. 1. Yes, it’s chaotic and uncertain right now, but get out of constant response mode. One of my biggest takeaways was the need to focus more on foresight . Nonprofits are operating in an environment where something new seems to demand our attention every day. The temptation is to keep responding to the latest policy change, headline, or crisis. But constantly reacting to chaos keeps us focused on what's happening to us, not what may be coming next. A useful set of questions from the summit: What's really going on? What's probably coming? What's possible? What could we do? Foresight is about recognizing the forces shaping what's next and deciding what they require of us now. We can’t predict the future, but we should be scanning the landscape to prepare for it. 2. Spend more time building your narrative than defending it. There will always be misinformation, harmful framing, and narratives we need to challenge. But defense shouldn't consume most of our energy. Instead of continually asking, "How do we respond to this?" we should also be asking: "Who can we move? Who can we mobilize? What do we want them to believe is possible?" That requires knowing the false dominant narratives we're up against, without letting them set our agenda. 3. Culture is part of the strategy. One of the summit's provocations was that culture, not capital, drives change. For philanthropy, especially, that's worth considering. Funding matters enormously. But lasting social change also depends on what people believe, who they trust, what they consider possible and what eventually becomes culturally accepted. That means the communications team doesn't work on narrative after the strategy is developed. Narrative is a critical part of the strategy. 4. Build community before you need it. This may be the simplest takeaway and perhaps the most important: relationships are infrastructure. When familiar patterns disappear, and people don't know what to believe, they look to people they trust to help them make sense of what's happening. We can't manufacture those relationships in the middle of a crisis. Relational organizing asks us to think differently about our networks: Who trusts us? Whom do we trust? Where are relationships strong? Where do we need to invest before the next difficult moment arrives? The summit framed the answer to division and chaos as beloved community , something that requires relationships, trust, and, yes, love. It requires us to love and care about people first and foremost. For nonprofit and philanthropic leaders, that means building more than audiences, email lists, or coalitions of convenience; it means building community. Kudos to the BMe Community for putting on the Summit and inviting Kairos to participate this year. This was definitely one of the best events I've attended in the last few years with the friendliest welcome faces (if I was greeted each morning by a cheer squad, there's so much more I would be motivated to get done in my day!). For those of us working toward social change, perhaps the question right now isn’t only, “What are we up against?” It’s also, “What are we building in its place, and who are we inviting to help us build it?” The challenges in front of us are real. But so is our capacity to imagine something better, bring people together around it, and begin building it now. That work requires more than resistance. It requires relationships, courage, creativity and a willingness to make room for more people to see themselves as part of the change. So, what are you building and who else needs to be at the table?
By Kristen Caloca • September 4, 2026
It’s hard out there right now, y’all. Nearly every nonprofit leader I know is navigating a mix of funding uncertainty, policy changes, rising costs, growing community need, workforce challenges, and general exhaustion. For many organizations, this isn’t a single crisis with a clear beginning and end. It’s one thing after another . It’s unrelenting. That was the backdrop for a conversation I recently had the honor of facilitating at the 2026 Partnership for Excellence conference , hosted by the Foundation Roundtable in Santa Barbara . I was joined by Erik Talkin, CEO of the Foodbank of Santa Barbara County , and Teresa Alvarez, Executive Director of the Carpinteria Children’s Project . Both shared candidly about what it has actually looked like to lead through multiple crises over the past two years. We grounded the conversation in story because (as you’ve heard me say before, screaming it from the rooftops) storytelling is a leadership practice for everyone . We also explored the role of adaptive leadership, particularly when the challenges in front of us can’t be solved by simply working harder or applying the same solutions we’ve used before. So how do we lead well when the crises don’t stop? At the conference, I shared a framework grounded in adaptive leadership and four capabilities I believe nonprofit leaders need right now: Anticipate. Adjust. Align. Advance. Think of these as four muscles leaders need to keep exercising at all times. ANTICIPATE: What is changing around us, and what might be coming next? When everything feels urgent, it’s easy to stay focused on what’s directly in front of us. Leadership requires lifting our heads and scanning the landscape. Pay attention to what’s changing. Challenge your assumptions. Lean into relationships. Talk with peers, funders, and partners about what they’re seeing. You don’t need to predict what happens next, but you do need to pay attention. ADAPT: What needs to change based on what we’re learning? Protecting the status quo can be one of the riskiest things we do in a changing environment. If we don’t adapt, change will eventually happen to us, and we’ll have fewer choices about how to respond (because hope is not a strategy). Adjusting doesn’t mean abandoning your mission. Sometimes it’s exactly what’s required to protect it. ALIGN: Who needs to be at the table, and what does our mission require of us right now? Crises create distractions. Mission creates clarity. So, get back to the basics: Why do we exist? Who are we here to serve? What must we protect, even if other things need to change? And don’t make those choices alone. Bring in your board. Listen to staff. Talk with partners. Center the people most impacted by your decisions. The vision for the future is not your burden alone. Leadership is only lonely if we let it be. ADVANCE: What opportunity might be emerging because of this moment? Crises disrupt old assumptions. They force decisions we’ve avoided and create opportunities to rethink how we work. Instead of only asking, “How do we get through this?” ask, “What could this moment make possible? How could this push us to innovate? What are we learning that could make us stronger? What should we change now to be better prepared for what comes next?" Reframing the moment is about building a more resilient, future-ready organization. As Erik shared during the session, “We are in a time where distraction and ‘flooding the zone’ are an intentional tactic to keep you stuck in a responsive mode and being defined by someone else’s agenda.” His advice? “Deal with the tactical whack-a-mole, but make sure there is time, money and focus left for what you know will define your work in the future.” There’s a difference between responding to a crisis and allowing the crisis to set your agenda. I closed our session with a poem from Wendell Berry, who passed away the day before our gathering. It felt like the right way to close a conversation about uncertainty, purpose, and what it means to keep moving when we can’t see exactly what comes next. No playbook exists for what is happening in today's volatile landscape. And there won't be a point anytime soon when everything settles down, and we can finally get back to “normal.” So perhaps part of the work is learning to lead differently within the uncertainty. Our communities and neighbors need organizations that can still dream, challenge the status quo, and co-create what comes next. Our future depends on it. The Peace of Wild Things by Wendell Berry When despair for the world grows in me and I wake in the night at the least sound in fear of what my life and my children’s lives may be, I go and lie down where the wood drake rests in his beauty on the water, and the great heron feeds. I come into the peace of wild things who do not tax their lives with forethought of grief. I come into the presence of still water. And I feel above me the day-blind stars waiting with their light. For a time I rest in the grace of the world, and am free.
Columbia Journalism Review cover titled “Figueroa Street and the Ethical Duty Care,” with black-and-white city collage and colored dots
By Kristen Caloca • July 1, 2026
Stories shape how we understand the world. They influence what we believe is possible, who we see as worthy of empathy, and ultimately the policies, systems, and investments that follow.
Kairos Pacific Strategy team graphic featuring Niko Rai, NextGen Changemaker Fellow, in a white shirt and tie
By Kristen Caloca • June 9, 2026
At Kairos Impact Strategies, we believe lasting community change requires investing in the next generation of leaders, advocates, and changemakers.
Six people posing in a conference room, two holding framed certificates in front of a projected screen.
By Kristen Caloca • May 14, 2026
The Role of Philanthropy in Building Narrative Leadership for Long-Term Nonprofit Sustainability
Two people stand outdoors smiling, one wearing a white grid-patterned top and the other in a black off-shoulder top.
By Kristen Caloca • March 28, 2026
In this spotlight, we’re hearing directly from two team members who bring both depth and clarity to our work every day: Andrea Vaudrey, Director of Operations, and Grace Granados, Communications Strategist.
Three people on a video call smiling. The top person is wearing glasses. The bottom has a Christmas tree.
By Kristen Caloca • February 24, 2026
A strong strategic plan is a living framework. It helps your organization define what matters most, communicate priorities with confidence, and build the habits that turn strategy into action, especially in moments of uncertainty and change, as in the current landscape.
Two women sit at a stone table with a laptop, smiling. Outdoors, near a building.
By Kristen Caloca • February 12, 2026
At Kairos Impact Strategies, we partner with nonprofits, foundations, and government agencies at inflection points: leadership transitions, funding shifts, policy opportunities, and sometimes even crises.
Rolling green mountains with a sea of clouds beneath a bright blue sky, small bird in the distance.
By Kristen Caloca • February 1, 2026
A New Case for Asset Framing: Lessons from San Diego’s Child and Family Wellbeing Transformation
Conference in Los Angeles with speakers on stage, large screens, and an audience in a large ballroom.
By Kristen Caloca • November 12, 2025
At the Center for Effective Philanthropy 2025 conference in Los Angeles last week all roads pointed to the same truth: systems change depends on narrative change. We recap why funders need to invest in strategic communications, storytelling and narrative strategy, not just programs, if they want to truly change outcomes.
Show More